Option A — The Breakdown

Clean sections: Verdicts → Head-to-Head → Agent Takes

Nabe Analysis
312 E 6th St
Best Overall
170 N 10th St
Good Deal
320 S 3rd St
Quietest
🔇
320 S 3rd is quieter (82 vs 72), but 312 E 6th has better management (90 vs 87)
💰
170 N 10th is priced below market. 320 S 3rd is above — but rare private terrace justifies it
⭐
312 E 6th wins on Nabe Score (94) by 4 points, but all three are above 90 — you can't go wrong
Agent Takes
EC
Emma Chen
312 E 6th St
"I've been in this neighborhood 15 years and this block is one of the quietest in the East Village. The garden alone is worth the price."
MR
Marcus Rivera
170 N 10th St
"This building has the best rooftop in the neighborhood — you can see the Manhattan skyline and the Williamsburg Bridge."
SK
Sarah Kim
320 S 3rd St
"This is the rare 3BR that actually feels like a 3BR — generous room sizes, not the typical NYC squeeze."
Option B — The Report Card

Per-listing mini cards with score bars, insights, quotes

Nabe Analysis
312 E 6th St
$1,800,000
Best Overall
Quiet
80
Mgmt
90
Walk
99
Transit
88
Private garden Top management Higher taxes
EC
"I've been in this neighborhood 15 years and this block is one of the quietest in the East Village."
170 N 10th St
$1,200,000
Good Deal
Quiet
72
Mgmt
87
Walk
96
Transit
91
Below market Rooftop views Higher charges
MR
"This building has the best rooftop in the neighborhood — Manhattan skyline and the Williamsburg Bridge."
320 S 3rd St
$6,200/mo
Quietest
Quiet
82
Mgmt
90
Walk
92
Transit
83
Private terrace Top management Higher price point
SK
"The rare 3BR that actually feels like a 3BR — generous room sizes, not the typical NYC squeeze."
Option C — Winner Takes All

Hero winner at top, runners-up compared against it

Nabe Analysis
🏆 Nabe's Pick
312 E 6th St
Highest Nabe Score + best management
94
Nabe Score
170 N 10th St
Saves you $600K · Quieter by 2pts · smaller sqft
91
320 S 3rd St
Quietest option (82) · Private terrace · highest price
90
The real tradeoffs
🔑 Want the best building? 312 E 6th — top management, private garden, quietest block in EV
💰 Want the best deal? 170 N 10th — below market price, killer rooftop, 3 points behind on score
🏡 Want space + quiet? 320 S 3rd — true 3BR with terrace, quietest of the three
Option D — The Magazine

Editorial: headline, callout boxes, pull quotes

Nabe Analysis
312 E 6th leads, but this is closer than it looks.
All three score 90+ — the difference is in what matters to you.
🔇
Noise: Closer than expected
320 S 3rd (82) edges out 312 E 6th (80). 170 N 10th trails at 72 — it's a busier block near the BQE.
💰
The value play
170 N 10th is priced below market — $600K less than 312 E 6th with only a 3-point score difference. Strongest ROI potential.
⚠️
What to watch
170 N 10th: common charges higher than average. 320 S 3rd: premium price for the area. 312 E 6th: higher property taxes for townhouse.
"I've been in this neighborhood 15 years and this block is one of the quietest in the East Village. The garden alone is worth the price — you won't find outdoor space like this below $2M anywhere nearby."
Agent take — 312 E 6th St
"This building has the best rooftop in the neighborhood — you can see the Manhattan skyline and the Williamsburg Bridge. The super, Ramon, is incredibly responsive."
Agent take — 170 N 10th St
"This is the rare 3BR that actually feels like a 3BR — generous room sizes, not the typical NYC squeeze. The private terrace is a game-changer for families."
Agent take — 320 S 3rd St
Option E — The Swipe Summary

Horizontal swipe cards — one per listing, all insights inside

Nabe Analysis
312 E 6th St
$1,800,000
Best Overall
Strengths
+ Quiet score 80/100 — quietest block in EV
+ Top-rated management (90/100)
+ Private garden with afternoon sun
Watch out
! Higher property taxes for townhouse
Agent take
"The garden alone is worth the price — you won't find outdoor space like this below $2M anywhere nearby."
170 N 10th St
$1,200,000
Good Deal
Strengths
+ Priced below market
+ Incredible rooftop with Manhattan views
+ Top-rated management (87/100)
Watch out
! Common charges higher than average
! Noisier location (quiet: 72)
Agent take
"The super, Ramon, is incredibly responsive and actually lives on-site. That's rare in Williamsburg."
320 S 3rd St
$6,200/mo
Quietest
Strengths
+ Quietest of the three (82/100)
+ Private terrace — rare in Brooklyn
+ True 3BR with generous room sizes
Watch out
! Higher price point for the area
Agent take
"The private terrace is a game-changer for families or anyone who entertains."

Swipe to see each listing's full analysis. None of this exists on other sites.